Putney was dragged back into the Brexit wars on Monday night, when our MP backed the Prime Minister’s EU push on Newsnight and a Labour colleague asked: Putney or Pendle?
Fleur Anderson, who campaigned for Burnham in Makerfield in June, appeared in a recorded clip on the BBC’s late-night news programme, the same night Andy Burnham told the Lord Mayor’s Banquet in the City that Britain had “lost more than we have gained” from leaving the EU.
“It’s not just people in Putney who will welcome this conversation,” she said. “Looking again at the EU and our relationship and getting back onto the international stage is definitely the right thing to do.”
Newsnight introduced her as the MP for an area where around three quarters of people voted Remain. Then it turned to Jonathan Hinder, Labour MP for Pendle and Clitheroe in Lancashire, sitting in the studio.
Presenter Victoria Derbyshire put to him a figure from the polling expert Professor Sir John Curtice: 82% of people who voted Labour in 2024 support rejoining the EU, according to YouGov. Was he out of step with colleagues like Anderson, and with many of his own party’s voters?
He had “no issue with Fleur representing her constituents’ views”, he said. Then he asked what Labour was for:
“Do we want to be for people in Putney, or people in Pendle, in industrial Britain, where working-class people traditionally would have voted Labour?”
Telling those voters “you’re wrong, you’re a thick northern racist, or whatever” would be a mistake, he went on. Derbyshire cut in: Burnham hadn’t said that, had he? “Obviously, he’s not saying that,” Hinder conceded.
Putney has form
None of this is new to Putney.
In the 2016 referendum, three in four voters in Wandsworth backed Remain, one of the strongest Remain votes in London. The country as a whole voted 51.9% to leave. Putney’s own result was never counted separately; estimates put it at between 72% and 73%.
Three years later, Putney’s Conservative MP, Justine Greening, was one of 21 Tory MPs to lose the party whip after voting against Boris Johnson’s government over a no-deal Brexit. The former education secretary, Putney’s MP since 2005, stood down at the election that December.
Putney then became the only seat in the country Labour gained, in an election that left the party with its fewest seats since 1935. The winner was Anderson, who had spoken at People’s Vote marches calling for a second referendum.

Ten years on from the referendum, Burnham has reopened the argument. “The hard Brexit we were given is not good enough for Britain,” he said on Monday. On Friday he goes to Brussels for a UK-EU summit, where he is expected to sign new deals with the EU on food, energy and youth mobility.
Also on Newsnight was Paul Johnson, who ran the Institute for Fiscal Studies for 14 years. On the economics, he said, “Mr Burnham is clearly right. We’ve lost more than we’ve gained.”
Hinder said he had no objection to easier trade with Europe, and that what had been agreed this week was in line with government policy. But free movement, the customs union and the euro were “out of the question” for him.
Then he answered his own question. At ten past midnight, Hinder shared the BBC’s clip of himself asking whether Labour was for “people in Putney, or people in Pendle”, and added: “Of course, we can be for BOTH. That’s what Labour is, at its best.”
On Tuesday afternoon, Anderson shared the same clip with an invitation. “Hi @Jonathan_Hinder I hope you can visit Putney with me very soon. I have a few people I’d like you to meet.”
He has not yet replied.