TfL has saved the 424 bus. It’s now literally faster to walk

One bus every 40 minutes means walking wins 96 per cent of the time
424 bus
The 424: slower than walking 96% of the time.

TfL has saved the 424 bus… and cut its timetable back so far that it is literally faster to walk.

The bus from Putney to Fulham will now turn up just once every 40 minutes, instead of every 30, as residents requested. The result is that it will literally be faster to walk 96 per cent of the time. Miss one narrowly, and walking wins every single time.

Go end to end, from the Green Man on Putney Heath to Fulham’s football ground, and the bus takes an hour and two minutes. You can walk it in 41. That’s because the bus winds through 7.6 miles (12.2km) of Putney and Fulham to reach somewhere just 2.1 miles (3.3km) away.

Watch the bus pull away from the Green Man, set off on foot, and you’ll be at Fulham FC 20 minutes before the bus you just missed.

It’s not just the end-to-end run though. If you are waiting at the top of Putney Hill, heading to Fulham Broadway and you’ve just missed the 424, if you just walked it, you would arrive more than half-an-hour earlier than waiting for the next bus.

Don’t believe us? We’ve worked out all 676 journeys you can make between two stops on the route. Pick yours on the map below, say whether you’ve just missed the bus or just turned up, and race it.

If you can’t walk it

All very well if you can walk two miles. But many of the people who rely on the 424 can’t. Nearly three in ten of its weekday passengers are older people on a Freedom Pass, and nearly one in 20 more use a disabled person’s pass, according to TfL’s own figures.

They told TfL so. It was the top worry in TfL’s consultation, raised in 82 comments. People who use the Sands End Community Centre said many of them are over 65 or have mobility problems, and rely on the 424 several times a week to get there.

For them there is no race, just a wait of up to 39 minutes. There is no 424 on a Sunday, and the last one of the day leaves the Green Man at 7.10pm.

People also told TfL they were worried about long waits and missed connections. TfL’s written response, in full: “Noted.”

‘A more reliable service’

TfL says cutting the service to a bus every 40 minutes “will allow for a more reliable service while still giving adequate value for money”.

Even if it ran perfectly to time, the 424 would still get to Fulham 21 minutes after someone who walked.

The 424 can’t keep to time. It has missed TfL’s punctuality target in every period for two years, and its latest score was 60.5 per cent against a target of 78. A year ago TfL wanted to split the route in two, blaming congestion on Putney High Street.

Back then the bus came every 35 minutes, and TfL wanted to make it every 45. Most people who answered told TfL that was “unworkable”, and many asked for a bus every 30 minutes or better. More than two in three, 168 of the 248 who answered, said splitting the route would make things worse for them.

It then took TfL ten months to decide. Its answer: drop the split, keep the route whole from Putney Heath to Fulham, and run it every 40 minutes. That is fewer buses than people already had, and further still from what they asked for. TfL calls it “slightly revised frequencies”.

To be fair to the 424, it does win if it is already sitting at the stop when you arrive. Then it is quicker on 488 of the 676 journeys. Its best run is Carslake Road to Sainsbury’s in Sands End: 29 minutes on board, against a 57-minute walk. Just miss that one, though, and walking still gets you there 11 minutes sooner.

Its worst: Fulham FC to Putney Bridge station. That’s 45 minutes on the bus, and 18 on foot.

The bus isn’t slow when it’s moving: just over 7mph, against 3mph on foot. It loses because it goes the long way round, and because the next one is so long in coming.

Our walking times assume a steady 3mph on the flat. Putney Hill is a climb, and some of the short cuts cross parks that may be shut after dark. But even at a gentle 2.5mph, walking beats the next bus on every journey on the route. You can set your own pace on the map.

Putney MP Fleur Anderson wrote to the Deputy Mayor for Transport, Seb Dance, two days before TfL’s decision, saying the 424 “should be retained in its current form”. She objected that TfL’s plans would “reduce the frequency of the service on the Putney section of the route”. In the consultation, she told TfL the main objection would be a bus every 45 minutes instead of every 30, according to TfL’s summary of her response.

We sent TfL our figures and asked whether it accepts them, whether it checked bus times against walking times before choosing 40 minutes, and why it chose 40 and not 30. It has yet not responded.

TfL hasn’t said when the 40-minute timetable becomes permanent. It says new electric buses will arrive “in due course”, and that its monitoring will continue “to ensure services match passenger demand”.

What you can do

Total
0
Shares
1 comment
  1. Thank you Kieren, I live near Craven Cottage and use the 424 frequently. I am somewhat disabled in that I cannot walk easily to Fulham Palace Road to find another bus due to respiratory problems so I rely heavily on this but to get me to GP, Hospital appointments, shopping etc. It’s extremely stressful wondering every day, is the bus going to turn up and if it does is it going to sit stationary at Craven Cottage for 20-30 minutes due to the inexplicable reasoning of Tfl that if a bus is running late or early it has to wait for the next scheduled time to leave. Apparently from the stop in Putney to Putney High Street, the driver is given something in the region of 20 minutes to get there, but they report it only takes 10 minutes which means they sit for 20 minutes with passengers on board eventually getting off and walking. I was on the bus one afternoon heading back to Craven Cottage when at the top of Munster Road the bus was stopped, to ‘even out the service’. I checked the time, he had just enough time to make it back in time to Craven Cottage for his scheduled departure. Sitting for 5 or so minutes still gave him time, however he crawled his way back so slowly that of course, he was late and had to remain stationary for 20-30 mins. I’ve also seen drivers parked up in side streets. When I complained about this to Tfl they said, ‘they have to have their breaks’. Well it’s the first time I have ever seen any London bus just turn into a side street, off route and sit on his mobile.

    So there you have it, my complaint. I live near many disabled and elderly and this bus has caused them more serious problems than I can go into here, not the least of which is isolation, they won’t risk leaving home now.

    Thanks again Kieran

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts
Total
0
Share